Articles

Date	Publication	Topic	AP	RA	Subject	Modes	Keywords	Standards	Rhetoric	Notes
1850-01-01	Germ	WMR Reviews Clough's Bothie	✓		literature	critical	Clough Bothie early review The Germ	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	Earliest review, Germ.
1850-02-01	Germ	WMR reviews Arnold's first poetry collection.			literature	critical	Arnold's 1st poetry collection The Germ	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Second WMR Germ review statement re: imitation
1850-05-01	Germ	WMR Reviews Browning	✓		literature	critical	Browning aesthetic & critical theory	PRB aesthetic standards naturalism	definitive	How to create, critique and read aesthetic naturalism.
1851-08-01	London Lit.	Refute Critic's review of Emerson	✓		literature	critical	Emerson portrait Scott Critic review	authenticity accuracy	rebuttal, definitive	Debunk Critic reviewer's Scott reference Reminiscences ref.
1852-03-15	London Lit.	Defense of WM Cayley's Dante translation			literature	polemical, critical	defend rebut; surprise dismay	ethos authenticity	rebuttal, definitive
1861-04-01	Fraser's	British sculpture past/present/future	✓		art	polemical, critical, educational	valuation public awareness	truth authenticity Greek classicism	definitive, evaluative, deliberative	Thanks W.B. Scott for praise in letter 28 April 1861.
1861-11-01	Fraser's	Fairness in Royal Academy exhibitions	✓	✓	art	polemical, critical	RA fairness efficiency aesthetics	ideals duty fairness	evaluative, proposal	Royal Academy shortcomings, unfairness.
1862-07-01	Fraser's	Academy 1862 exhibition, flawed RA standards	✓	✓	art	polemical, critical	authenticity aesthetic standards fairness	classical "high" art	evaluative, definitive	Royal Academy shortcomings.
1863-06-01	Fraser's	RA exhibition, RA change, PRB influence	✓	✓	art	critical	RA policy shift PRB influence Brit school	current practice potential change value	evaluative, deliberative	Extends June 63 Fraser's "cannot stop short" Chapman ref Letters .
1865-04-08	Athenaeum	Refute review, correct facts			literature	polemical	correction interpretation reference	linguistic truth authenticity correctness	definitive	WMR Dante translation defended.
1865-04-15	Athenaeum	Reinforce WMR's previous translation			literature	polemical, critical	comparison w/15c. Word usage	comparison w/15c. Word	definitive
1865-05-01	Fraser's	Madox Brown as WMR aesthetic exemplar	✓		art	critical, educational, historical	Brown exh. movements PRB	examples history analysis	evaluative, definitive, deliberative	See also MB frescoes in Manchester.
1865-06-01	Fraser's	Royal Academy Exhibition	✓	✓	art	critical	professional criticism public awareness duty	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, deliberative	Ref: Reminiscences 1 PRB preference, RA Academy change hanging
1866-10-01	FAQR	Palgrave; role & function of critic	✓		art	polemical, critical, educational	professional criticism classical standards	classical vs. contemporary concepts	definitive, deliberative	Photography/critic: clarity refers to Palgrave 14 Aug 65 WBS letter.
1868-04-25	Examiner	Refute criticism of WMR editorial work on Whitman	✓		literature	polemical, historical	refute defend correct	accuracy clarification facts	rebuttal, definitive	Multiple Letters/Reminiscences refs included
1868-10-01	Athenaeum	Explain possible WMR Chaucer error			literature	critical	correct explain Latin derivative and use	accuracy Latin connotation	definitive
1869-07-17	Athenaeum	Deny connection between WMR and RA pamphlet		✓	art	polemical, historical	deny refute truth RA treachery	fact truth	rebuttal, definitive
1869-11-13	Academy	WMR review of Brisbane's collection of Alexander Smith			literature	critical, educational	poetics aesthetics imagery	aesthetic poetry imagery	evaluative	Letters cross reference.
1870-01-01	Portfolio	Contemp. painters vs. PRB principles & potential	✓		art	critical, polemical, educational	authenticity aesthetic standards fairness	authenticity PRB principles	definitive, deliberative
1870-08-13	Academy	WMR review of Keningale Robert Cook			literature	critical	poetics aesthetics imagery effectiveness	aesthetic poetry imagery	evaluative, definitive
1871-01-01	Fortnightly	Newly discovered docs related to Shelley			literature	historical, educational	discovery explanation documentation bio	historical artifacts facts	definitive, evaluative	Shelley: new documents.
1871-03-01	Academy	WMR review of FG Stephens' volume of collected satire			literature	critical, historical	satire evaluation comparison detail	definition range history	evaluative
1871-06-15	Academy	WMR review of Joaquin Miller's "Songs of the Sierras"	✓		literature	critical	aesthetic principles illustrative imagery	aesthetic poetic principles	definitive, evaluative	American poet refs Letters and Reminiscences 2.
1872-04-01	Academy	WMR comparative review of 2 ref works on Dante			literature	critical	comparison value accuracy	comparison value achievement	evaluative
1872-04-15	Academy	WMR review of J.Murray's translation of Elze's Byron			literature	critical, historical	accuracy translation fact documents	accuracy facts fairness translation	evaluative, deliberative
1872-07-13	Athenaeum	Clarify Mary Queen of Scots verses			literature	critical, historical	accuracy connotation context	context connotation	evaluative
1872-09-01	Dark Blue	WMR review of DeVirgilii's poetic achievement			literature	critical, educational	romanticism poetic imagery effectiveness	achievement effectiveness	evaluative
1872-12-01	Academy	WMR review of D.F. MacCarthy's Shelley bio			literature	critical, historical	completeness accuracy fairness	facts analyzed validated/debunked	evaluative
1873-06-02	Academy	William Davis memorialized, RA failures		✓	art	critical	aesthetic principles RA failures	comparison evaluation	epideictic, evaluative	Heart attack brought on by bad hanging.
1873-12-01	Academy	WMR debunks Raphael attribution			art	critical, historical	accuracy context facts probability	context value	deliberative, evaluative
1874-01-01	Academy	WMR review of Landseer exhibition			art	critical	achievement PRB ascendance	lifetime achievement rank	evaluative, epideictic
1874-01-03	Academy	Memorialize Landseer, publicize exhibition			art	critical, historical	memorial achievement rank	relative merit accomplishment	evaluative
1874-01-03	Academy	Exhibition of Cox & De Wint watercolors			art	critical	achievement comparison to Turner	worthy aesthetic execution	evaluative
1874-01-31	Academy	WMR review of WH Wilshire reference book			literature	critical, educational	artisanship achievement engraving	thoroughness comparative merit	evaluative, definitive
1874-02-07	Academy	Dudley Gallery, part 1			art	critical, polemical	mediocrity poor quality low achievement	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Hanging gripe.
1874-02-14	Academy	Dudley Gallery, part 2			art	critical	mediocrity poor quality low achievement	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1874-02-28	Academy	WMR reviews Garnett's edition of Shelley			literature	historical	inaccuracy mistranslation omission	facts history	evaluative	Shelley edition, disputed emendations.
1874-03-21	Academy	WMR review of FG Stephens' vol. 2 of collected satire			art lit	critical, historical	satire evaluation comparison detail	definition range history; accuracy	evaluative, deliberative	Vol 1 reviewed March 1871.
1874-03-21	Academy	Announce Simpson's "Round the world" exhibit			art	journalistic	Simpson exhibition world pictures	fact news	definitive	Equivocates criticism announcement mostly.
1874-03-28	Academy	Society of Lady Artists exhibition			art	critical, historical	relative merit imagery "ambisexual" art	poesy imagery rank merit	evaluative
1874-04-18	Academy	WMR notice of 2 Regnault oil paintings			art	critical, polemical	social &aesthetic standards	rank execution design PRB	evaluative, definitive	Ref. Memoir 2.
1874-06-20	Academy	Cole's Intn'l Exhibition; Quality & Bias			art	critical, polemical, educational	RA deficiency definition standards	PRB standards RA strictures	evaluative, deliberative	RA, poor quality foreign art, bias Cole controversy, letters ref.
1874-06-27	Academy	Munich Gallery exhibition			art	critical, polemical, educational	accuracy quality rank	PRB standards value accomplishment	evaluative, deliberative	"the inner hierarchy of art . . ."
1874-08-15	Academy	Dore Gallery			art	critical	achievement excellence success	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	"Over-prolific French master"
1874-09-05	Academy	WMR memorializes JH Foley			art	critical, historical, educational	sculpture preeminence rank	lifetime achievement rank	epideictic, definitive	Suggests RA elect Woolner to replace Foley done Dec 12 74 Academy.
1874-09-05	Academy	WMR reviews Shepard's "Blake"			literature	critical	accuracy Blake edition Shepard ed.	accuracy precision	evaluative, definitive	Blake edition, Shepard ed.
1874-10-31	Academy	WMR reviews W. Stillman's historical narrative			literature	critical	narrative history Cretan insurrection	facts history	evaluative	Stillman former US ambassador to Greece see Letters, 141.
1874-10-31	Academy	Dudley Gallery			art	critical	cabinet pictures oil	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative
1874-10-10	Academy	Rebut Blake publisher criticism of WMR review			literature	critical, polemical	copyright accuracy facts rebuttal	facts analyzed validated/debunked	evaluative, rebuttal	WMR Blake review Sep. 5, 1874, Academy.
1874-11-07	Academy	WMR reviews "The New British Institution"			art	critical, polemical	trivial intellectual realism reproductive art	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, deliberative	Not all French ". . . sometimes to be called stupid."
1874-11-21	Academy	Society of French Artists, part 1			art	critical	execution intellectual content importance	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1874-11-28	Academy	Society of French Artists, part 2			art	critical	execution intellectual content importance	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Part 2. The importance of a well-executed national art school.
1874-12-05	Academy	Society of British Artists			art	critical, polemical	purposeless bad art	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1874-12-12	Academy	WMR pans Flemish Gallery exhibition			art	critical, polemical	foreign schools not all Flemish low art	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Leys, 1 painting not all Flemish work on page: Woolner replaces Foley RA.
1874-12-19	Academy	New docs support MacCarthy's Shelley account			literature	historical, critical	new docs Oxford pub & expulsion	historical artifacts facts	definitive, evaluative	Shelley, 12-1872 orig. WMR review of MacCarthy's Shelley.
1874-12-19	Academy	Riddell's personal Blake mss.			literature	critical, historical	Riddell volume Burns poetry	historical artifacts facts	evaluative	Burns, personal volume of Riddell.
1875-01-09	Academy	Water-Colour Society Gallery, "Sketches/Studies"			art	critical	annual exhibition relative merit watercolor	PRB aesthetic standards value	evaluative	WMR picturesque prose "Younger RA members stand out."
1875-01-16	Academy	Water-Colour Society Gallery, part 2.			art	critical	water-colour achievement merit value	PRB aesthetic standards past practice	evaluative	Ruskin's paintings reviewed.
1875-02-02	Academy	Dudley Gallery, second notice			art	critical	Dudley portraits/landscapes female painters	PRB aesthetic standards past practice	evaluative	High percentage of female painters.
1875-02-06	Academy	Dudley Gallery, first notice			art	critical, educational	poetic painting; water-colour exhibition	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Poynter as poetic painting exemplar, catalogue sonnet.
1875-02-13	Academy	Agnew exhib. "High-class Watercolour Drawings"			art	critical	Priv. exhib. Agnew water-colour	PRB aesthetic standards past practice	evaluative	Painted by William Millais noted.
1875-03-13	Academy	The New British Institution			art	critical	New Brit. Inst.; foreign art excess exhibit	PRB aesthetics authenticity	evaluative, definitive	Questions "Institution painting from Antwerp, "Circle of Pigs."
1875-03-13	Academy	Mr. J. Birnie Philips			art	memorial	Compare Birnie Philip w/Armstead	PRB aesthetic standards body of work	definitive, evaluative	Sculptors compared, Philip deceased.
1875-03-20	Academy	Paintings by Elijah Walton			art	critical, journalistic	announce collection evaluate Walton	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Single-painter exhibit.
1875-03-27	Academy	The Linnell exhibition			art	critical, polemical	Linnell Pall Mall E.T. White	PRB aesthetic standards exhib. Stds.	evaluative	Criticizes inclusion of "trade-interest" works photography compared.
1875-03-27	Academy	WMR review Marston's "All in All: Poems & Sonnets"			literature	critical	volume reviewed Marston	classic poetic constructs and achievement	evaluative	Cheyne Walk Circle comp. to DGR, Swinburne, Shelley.
1875-04-10	Academy	WMR pans Belgian Gallery & promoter			art	critical, polemical, educational	Belgian gallery poor quality	aesthetic norms value accomplishment	evaluative, definitive	Forgery of Landseer cheap art at expensive of Brit art public.
1875-04-10	Academy	French Gallery			art	critical, polemical	continental art; non-Academy	PRB aesthetic standards non-RA	evaluative, definitive	Direct comparison to early PRB.
1875-05-01	Academy	Water-Colour Institute, second notice			art	critical	landscapes watercolor	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Brief notice.
1875-05-15	Academy	Royal Academy, second notice		✓	art	critical, polemical	RA exhibition historical & general subjects	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Albert Moore "fatuity of praise" Prince of Wales, "led like asses."
1875-05-22	Academy	Royal Academy, third notice		✓	art	critical	RA domestic and general subjects	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Cheyne Walk Circle Millais, foreign schools..
1875-05-22	Academy	Society of French Art exhibition			art	critical	sub-std art patronage uninformed market	aesthetic standards	evaluative	Poor art + uninformed buyers = loss for good art. Cheyne Walk cir.
1875-05-29	Academy	Society of French Artists, second notice			art	critical	exhibition analysis critique commentary	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Tadema reference x 3 members Cheyne Walk circle.
1875-05-29	Academy	Water-Colour Society, second notice			art	critical	Water-Colour Society landscapes animals	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative
1875-06-05	Academy	Royal Academy, fourth notice		✓	art	critical	exhibition analysis critique commentary	RA exhibition relative merit	evaluative
1875-06-12	Academy	Goupil's "gallery"			art	critical, polemical	Goupil "fashionable art;" low-merit art	PRB aesthetic standards	definitive, evaluative	Debunk "paid" exhibit def. "fashionable" works .
1875-06-12	Academy	WMR memorializes Walker			art	historical	Walker memorialized	Comparative merit of Walker's work	epideictic	def. naturalness in art.
1875-06-19	Academy	Royal Academy, fifth notice		✓	art	critical	portraits & animals RA 1875 PRB artists	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	PRB exemplified stds. hanging problems w/RA.
1875-06-26	Academy	The International Exhibition			art	critical, polemical	"worthless" exhib. illegitimate means $ v. art	classical aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	Strongest condemnation art of "illegitimate means."
1875-07-03	Academy	Royal Academy, sixth notice		✓	art	critical	landscapes "Hook-scapes" poetic imagery	PRB aesthetic standards poetic imagery	evaluative	"Landscape description seldom an attractive operation."
1875-07-10	Academy	WMR visits La Maison Leys, Antwerp			art	historical	Baron Ley's home artwork bio. frescoes	Tour of Maison Leys Antwerp	definitive	Peripatetic physicality, narration.
1875-07-17	Academy	Royal Academy, final notice		✓	art	critical, educational	etch/draw/sculpture/architecture RA	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, deliberative	First purpose, good art, not good price. "Sterling art for sterling coin"
1875-07-31	Academy	Madox-Brown's "King Lear"	✓		art lit	critical, polemical	Brown Lear intertextuality: art lit drama	dramatic poetic aesthetic value	definitive, evaluative	Intertextuality: art-lit-drama RA type degrade Cheyne Walk Circle.
1875-10-03	Academy	Dudley Gallery, first notice			art	critical, polemical	Dudley oils Whistler Watts Hughes	PRB aesthetic standards past exhibs.	evaluative	Whistler noted as "leading exhibitor of the year."
1875-10-09	Academy	Royal Academy Photo Album		✓	art	critical, polemical	RA Album photographed art problems	results appropriateness fairness	evaluative	First WMR re: photography PRB best of year vs. RA.
1875-11-06	Academy	Dudley Gallery, second notice			art	critical	Dudley landscapes figures animals	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Leslie rebuke for $ painting.
1875-11-13	Academy	Frere collection			art	critical	Frere collection Agnew Waterloo Place	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Cites critical "over-praising" of Frere uninformed patronage.
1875-11-27	Academy	Society of French Artists exhibition			art	critical	Soc. French artists figures landscapes flowers	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Whistler prominent.
1875-12-04	Academy	WMR memorializes Alfred Boyd Houghton			art	journalistic, critical	Houghton obituary/memorial	lifetime achievement rank	epideictic
1875-12-04	Musical W.	WMR presents new evidence re: Shelley murder			literature	journalistic, historical	Shelley?s death murder evidence confession.	letter from Trelawney's daughter	definitive	WMR cites this letter in later lectures/essays.
1875-12-04	Academy	WMR reconstructs Shelley's drowning			literature	historical, journalistic, educational	Shelley's death murder evidence	multiple sources witness confession	definitive	WMR cites this letter in later lectures/essays.
1875-12-11	Academy	Water Colour Institute			art	critical	water-colour achievement merit value	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Part 1 landscapes reserved for part 2 "like DGR" reference.
1875-12-18	Academy	Society of British Artists exhibition			art	critical	comparative value accomplishment merit	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Part 1 of 2 PRB comp., Japanese-mania.
1875-12-25	Academy	Brit. Artists & Watercolour Inst./Soc. Brit. Artists			art	critical	wrap up 2 other reviews of 2 groups/exh.	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Female painters reviewed on par combo review Shelley.
1876-01-29	Academy	Obit. Of Sir Geo. Harvey, Royal Scottish Acad. Pres.			art	journalistic	Harvey Scottish Academy pres. successor	historical fact	epideictic, deliberative	Recommends Paton as successor.
1876-02-05	Academy	Dudley Gallery			art	critical, polemical	Dudley mediocre exhibition	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Only "a respectable mediocrity."
1876-02-12	Academy	Dudley Gallery, second notice			art	critical	Dudley landscapes figures animals	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1876-02-26	Academy	Pinwell Exhibition			art	critical	Pinwell Exhibition and memorial	PRB aesthetic standards quality	evaluative	"Good qualities as a person, but not as a body of work."
1876-03-11	Academy	Blake exhibit at Burlington Club			art	critical	Blake exhibition Burlington Club	classical aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	Swinburne's "Blake" referenced.
1876-03-25	Academy	Benjamin Robert Haydon memoir			art lit	critical, polemical, historical	Haydon's life letters associations	merit ill humor failures	evaluative, definitive	Position piece: Brit valuation of art RA fails.
1876-03-01	Macmillan's	How W.S. Bell sets the poetic standard since Byron	✓		literature	critical	Byronic Shelleyan poetics; poetics and art	aesthetic value success	evaluative, definitive	Ref. letters 31 May 75: right of remonstrance intent 23 Aug 75.
1876-04-01	Academy	French Gallery			art	critical	Fr. Exhib.; Salon 1875 aesthetic imagery	PRB aesthetic standards value	evaluative	Strict school adherence, "homage to genius"
1876-04-01	Academy	WMR reviews Hake's "New Symbols" poetry collection	✓		literature	critical, educational	Hake "New Symbols" poetic imagery met.	poetic theory aesthetic imagery	evaluative, definitive	Reader authority imagination and invention, symbolism.
1876-04-08	Academy	Society of British Artists, first notice			art	critical	landscapes exhibit	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Some exhibitors dissuaded or hung inconspicuously.
1876-04-08	Academy	WMR refutes Hayden			literature	critical, polemical	WMR claims Hayden Casanova incorrect	Knowledge of Italian	rebuttal	". . . absolute gibberish."
1876-04-15	Athenaeum	WMR rebuts Watts			art lit	journalistic	3 points re: Bailey's "Festus"	dates editions facts.	rebuttal, definitive
1876-04-15	Academy	WMR corrects Scott's Blake catalogue			art lit	critical	Scott Blake catalogue corrections	firsthand knowledge	definitive	Lee
1876-04-22	Academy	French Gallery, second notice			art	critical	French Gallery other schools; modishness	PRB aesthetics relative merit	evaluative	"newfangled modishness" suited to "full pocketbooks, empty heads"
1876-04-29	Academy	Society of British Artists, second notice			art	critical	Soc. Brit. Art. figures landscapes water-c.	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Intertextuality: Tennyson x 2.
1876-05-06	Academy	King Street Galleries exhibit			art	critical, polemical	dealer's collection British & Foreign art	PRB aesthics relative merit	evaluative, definitive	dealer's collection, artists' risk ordinary.
1876-05-13	Academy	Royal Academy, second notice		✓	art	critical, journalistic	RA exhib. figures oriental	PRB aesthetic standards relative merit	evaluative	Extensive commentary: fault-finding, sub-standard.
1876-05-20	Academy	Water-Colour Society, second notice			art	critical	water-colours landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards relative merit	evaluative	Carlyle, Tennyson exhibit an "agreeable mediocrity."
1876-05-27	Academy	Royal Academy, third notice		✓	art	critical	domestic landscape portrait RA	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	3 categories for portraits Millais criticism.
1876-06-01	Academy	Goupil's "gallery"			art	critical, polemical	Goupil's commercialism	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	"Epoch of nouveaue riche" Fortuny, Gerome.
1876-06-03	Academy	Royal Academy, fourth notice		✓	art	critical	Water-colour Animal Etch/Engr Sculpture	PRB aesthetics comparative merit	evaluative	PRB artists, sculpture = highlight of exhibition.
1876-06-10	Academy	Date of Keats's death			literature	journalistic	Mrs. Shelley/Shelley "misdemeanant"	facts	definitive	Shelley vague, Mrs. Shelley mistaken WMR mislead.
1876-06-17	Academy	Black-and-White Exhibition			art	critical	B&W drawings etching engraving	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Gilchrist-Blake-Dadd reference.
1876-06-17	Academy	The Mignot Collection			art	critical, memorial	Mignot memorial	artistic merit relative accomplishment	definitive, epideictic	American landscaper died at 39, "could have used more experience."
1876-06-24	Academy	Landseer's Indian Views and Sketches			art	critical, journalistic	art from India Geo. Landseer	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	Distinguishes between prince of Wales' travel & exhib.
1876-07-01	Academy	Black-and-White Exhibition, second notice			art	critical	drawings etchings black-and-white	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1876-07-22	Academy	Oppermann biography of Sculptor Ernst Rietschel			art lit	journalistic	review/present bio	translation accuracy merit	definitive
1876-10-28	Examiner	WMR defends his Shelley edits from Forman	✓		literature	critical, historical, polemical	WMR Shelley edits Examiner Forman	WMR editorial standards	rebuttal, definitive	3 xref see also WMR reviews Forman 77.10.13.
1876-11-11	Academy	The French Gallery			art	critical, polemical	French Gallery bad painting	PRB aesthetic standard	evaluative	Works down to the "decidedly stupid" Long "Lame Ducks."
1876-11-18	Academy	Pictures in the Haymarket			art	critical	Tooth McLean Coleman Millais	PRB aesthetic standards relative merit	evaluative	170 works.
1876-11-25	Academy	Mr. Deschamps' Gallery, second notice			art	critical	Deschamps' figures landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1876-12-02	Academy	Society of British Artists, second notice			art	critical	landscapes figures still-lifes watercolors	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	"Carlyean countenance."
1876-12-16	Academy	The Water-Colour Society			art	critical	15th Winter Exhib. Of Sketches & Studies	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	". . . a good deal to like, and not much to denounce."
1876-12-23	Academy	The Water-Colour Society, second notice			art	critical	single figs. landscape water-colours	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Mrs. Allingham one of few females who can do any art medium .
1877-01-06	Academy	The Water-Colour Institute			art	critical	water-colour figures landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	WMR explains intellectual-dramatic link vs. Linton.
1877-01-20	Academy	WMR reviews Castelar's "Byron & Sketches"			literature	critical, historical	Castelar Byron sketch others	English writing standard facts	evaluative	Errors no translator could make this read English.
1877-02-10	Academy	Dudley Gallery, first notice			art	critical	Dudley figures landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative
1877-02-24	Academy	Dudley Gallery, second notice			art	critical	Dudley figures landscapes animals	PRB aesthetic standards	definitive	Mostly listings, little analysis.
1877-03-17	Academy	Suffolk Street Gallery			art	critical	Suffolk Street landscape figures	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	". . . a photographic air of sudden, spontaneous truth."
1877-03-24	Academy	Suffolk Street Gallery, second notice			art	critical	Suffolk Street landscape figures	PRB aesthetics relative merit	evaluative	Hanging gripe.
1877-04-07	Academy	Continental Exhibition			art	critical, polemical	Continental Fortuny school	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Fortuny school "must always be distasteful . . ."
1877-04-21	Academy	Continental Exhibition, second notice			art	critical, polemical	Continental French German Spanish	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative, definitive	"Repulsive, ugly" vogue caricaturing of Catholic clergy.
1877-04-28	Academy	Messrs. Goupil's Gallery			art	critical, polemical	foreign pictures Fortuny	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Fortuny school "flawed" Goupils "speculators."
1877-05-05	Academy	Grosvenor Gallery exhibition			art	critical, polemical	Grosvenor d?cor exhibit	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	Extended physical description of gallery, hanging gripe.
1877-05-12	Academy	Royal Academy, first notice		✓	art	critical	RA exhibition; achievement relative merit	RA/PRB standards	evaluative, definitive	2nd part
1877-05-19	Academy	Royal Academy, second notice		✓	art	critical	1877 RA exhibition comparative merit	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	RA hanging gripe Leighton & Millais " prime distinction of 77 RA."
1877-06-02	Academy	Royal Academy, third notice		✓	art	critical	RA exhib. WMR advice to painters	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative, definitive	RA, WMR advice to new painters RA "diploma painting" fault.
1877-06-09	Academy	Exhibitions: Miss Thompson, M. Pichio			art	critical	Miss Thompson Pichio Hugo	facts comparative merit achievement	evaluative, definitive	Victor Hugo comment.
1877-06-16	Academy	Royal Academy, fourth notice		✓	art	critical	sculpture water-colours	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Leighton's sculpture best Coleridge/Poe Marie Antoinette
1877-07-21	Academy	WMR reviews Redgrave's Historical Catalogue		✓	art lit	critical, polemical	Kensington exhib. Cat.; RA "henchmen"	concise accurate writing facts	evaluative, definitive	"The cloven feet of the henchmen of the Royal Academy . . ."
1877-10-13	Academy	WMR reviews Forman's "Shelley"			literature	critical, polemical	Forman Shelley WMR	accurate authentic correct editing	evaluative	Shelley, see also WMR defends his Shelley from Forman, 1876.10.28.
1877-10-15	Academy	WMR reviews Douglas's "Burns"			literature	critical	Burns notes vs. glossary 7 new works	Clarity completeness accuracy	evaluative	7 new works glossary vs. notes WBS ref.
1877-11-03	Academy	Pictures, British and Foreign, French Gallery			art	critical	Brit. & Foreign Wilkie	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Shelley verse vs. imagery of Max.
1877-11-24	Academy	Society of British Artists			art	critical, polemical	Soc. Brit. Art. pictures & sketches	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative, deliberative	Insight into Soc. membership artists "damaging" see also 78.04.06
1877-12-01	Academy	Dudley Gallery			art	critical	Dudley landscapes figures sculpture	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Dudley standard as mediocre consistently.
1877-12-08	Academy	Water-Colour Society			art	critical	water-colours figures landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Suggests 3 rather than 1 head model for Macbeth.
1877-12-15	Academy	Water-Colour Institute			art	critical	water-colours figures landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1877-12-29	Academy	Water Colour Society, second notice			art	critical	landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Primacy of sentiment catalog.
1878-01-05	Academy	Death of Gustave Courbet			art	historical	Courbet memorialized	historical perspective achievement	epideictic	". . . acted more to get rid of an obnoxious piece of bad art."
1878-01-19	Academy	WMR discounts Smith's Shelley biography			literature	critical, historical, polemical	Shelley bio. Smith Trelawney	facts historical accounts	evaluative	WMR cites 3 levels of error.
1878-02-23	Academy	Blake's Jerusalem, Bell-Scott's Blake etchings			art	critical	facsimile Jerusalem Bell-Scott's etchings	authenticity effective publication	evaluative, definitive	Facsimile & complications, Swinburne ref, see also 1876.03.11.
1878-02-01	University	WMR Shelley lecture, part 1			literature	critical, historical, educational	Shelley's history events work	historical & critical accuracy	definitive	Shelley: 2 part series, for uninformed, Rossetti Reminiscences 2:482
1878-03-09	Academy	Dudley Gallery			art	critical	critique evaluation comparison	artistic value authenticity truth	evaluative, definitive
1878-03-23	Academy	Dudley gallery, second notice			art	critical	Dudley hanging Stillman	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Mrs. Stillman hanging gripe.
1878-03-01	University	WMR Shelley lecture, part 2			literature	historical, educational	biography history Shelley education	facts history	definitive	Rossetti Reminiscences 2:482
1878-04-06	Academy	Soc. Brit. Art. New gallery/ RA & Grosvenor		✓	art	critical, polemical	new Conduit gallery RA Grosvenor	PRB aesthetics	evaluative	See also Soc. Brit. Artists review 78.11.24
1878-04-13	Academy	Messrs. Goupil's Gallery			art	critical	Goupil continental pictures	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1878-04-20	Academy	Water-Colour Institute			art	critical	Water-Colour Institute birds landscapes	PRB aesthetic standards merit	evaluative	Linton/Cheyne
1878-05-11	Academy	Royal Academy, first notice		✓	art	critical, polemical	uninteresting bad RA exhibition	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative
1878-05-18	Academy	Grosvenor Gallery exhibition			art	critical, polemical	value effectiveness authenticity	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative, definitive	Aesthetic theory: large PRB/Cheyne contingent as exemplar.
1878-05-25	Academy	Royal Academy, second notice		✓	art	critical	quality comparison aesthetic accomplishment	authenticity PRB principles	evaluative, definitive
1878-06-01	Academy	Grosvenor Gallery, second notice			art	critical	princess landscape figures sculpture	PRB aesthetics merit	evaluative	Special assessment for Princess Louise.
1878-06-08	Academy	Sale of Shelley artifacts and items			literature	critical, historical	Shelley possessions artifacts sale	facts historical accounts	definitive
1878-06-08	Academy	Royal Academy, third notice		✓	art	critical	RA landscapes figures animals	PRB aesthetic standards	evaluative	Millais predominates.
1878-06-15	Academy	WMR reviews Trelawney's "Records of Shelley & Byron"			literature	critical	Trelawney Shelley Byron records	accuracy readability facts	evaluative, definitive	Byron relics mentioned, compares Hogg/Mrs. Shelley/Trelawney
1878-06-22	Academy	WMR reviews T. Moore's Prose, Verse Satire, Shelley			literature	critical, historical	literary enquirers accuracy literary value	historical & contextual accuracy	evaluative
1878-09-07	Athenaeum	Correcting line from Dante pub. 8/17/78			literature	critical, historical	accurate translation	language standards	definitive	Responds to August 17, 1878 article.
1880-05-29	Athenaeum	Memorializing Seymour Kirkup			literature	historical	Dantesque literature expert obituary	encomium	epideictic	Reminiscences 2: sofa, Trelawney Letters 3x.
1880-11-13	Athenaeum	WMR critical dispute with Quilter			literature	polemical, critical	dispute correction challenge	facts according to WMR	rebuttal, definitive	Also Nov MacMillan's: WMR re: DGR and Swinburne
1880-11-01	Macmillan's	WMR refutes Quilter/Quilter makes his point			literature	polemical	rebuttal critique disagreement feud	facts according to WMR	rebuttal, definitive	Letters, Athenaeum Nov 13, 1880.
1881-01-01	Mag. of Art	WMR history of PRB movement	✓		art	historical, educational	PRB history first-person	facts history	definitive	PRB foundational, essential WMR history of PRB
1881-05-07	Athenaeum	WMR original poem for daughter turning 5			literature		commemoration	poetic theory	epideictic	original poem by WMR upon daughter reaching census age.
1881-06-01	Art Journal	Madox Brown's frescoes in Manchester	✓		art	critical, educational	frescos Manchester technique	aesthetic success execution authenticity	evaluative, definitive	Letters, Reminiscences 1&2, civic art, national artists.
1882-04-29	Athenaeum	Clarify DGR exhibition plans			art	journalistic	clarify DGR exhibition plans	facts changes	definitive	Letters: "leave path open for R.A."
1882-05-06	Athenaeum	Clarify term in Chaucer's "Eclympasteyre"			literature	critical	theory translation language derivative	French	definitive
1882-07-15	Athenaeum	WMR Trelawney journal part 1			literature	historical, educational	Trelawney and Shelley; WMR visits	journal entries	definitive	Shelley cremation WMR receives artifact.
1882-07-29	Athenaeum	WMR Trelawney journal part 2			literature	historical, educational	Trelawney and Shelley; WMR visits	journal entries	definitive
1882-08-05	Athenaeum	WMR Trelawney journal part 3			literature	historical, educational	Trelawney and Shelley; WMR visits	journal entries	definitive
1883-01-20	Athenaeum	Correct error re: DGR "Found" in RA guide			art	critical, historical	RA guide error DGR "Found"	facts according to WMR	definitive, rebuttal	WMR says RA has wrong source.
1884-03-10	Athenaeum	Clarify copyright claim			literature	critical	Tibbs copyright claim re: WMR	historical accuracy first-person ref.	definitive, rebuttal
1884-05-01	Art Journal	Notes on DGR & works, part 1	✓		art	historical, critical, educational	DGR works context history achievement	facts history	definitive, evaluative	"Task falls to his brother . . ."
1884-06-01	Art Journal	Notes on DGR & works, part 2	✓		art	historical, critical, educational	DGR works context history achievement	facts history	definitive, evaluative	Debunks DGR myths.
1886-02-13	Athenaeum	Shelley Society Mtg. notice & member solicitation			literature	journalistic, educational	Shelley Society news	facts news	definitive, deliberative	Shelley: recruiting for Shelley Society.
1886-07-01	Art Journal	Notes on DGR & works, part 3			art	critical, historical, educational	DGR works context history achievement	facts history	definitive, evaluative	Final installment deathbed.
1889-01-20	Mag. of Art	Portraits of DGR, part 2			art	critical, historical, educational	DGR portraits 1853-82	historical context achievement	definitive, evaluative	context, Carroll photography.
1889-01-30	Mag. of Art	Portraits of DGR, part 3			art	critical, historical, educational	DGR photos deathbed tributes	historical context memorial	definitive, evaluative	context, Carroll photography deathbed of DGR.
1889-01-01	Mag. of Art	Portraits of DGR, part 1			art	critical, historical, educational	DGR works context history achievement	historical context memorial	definitive, evaluative	Brotherly admiration and tribute.
1889-04-01	Hobby H.	Ford Madox Brown's paintings	✓		art	critical, educational	Brown PRB standards poetic effect image	PRB standards aesthetic value	definitive, evaluative	Brown as exemplar of PRB precepts in successful execution.
1890-01-20	Mag. of Art	Portraits of Browning, part 2			art lit	historical, educational, critical	Browning bio. via history w/portraits	first-person recall portraits	definitive
1890-01-30	Mag. of Art	Portraits of Browning, part 3			art lit	historical, educational, critical	Browning bio. via history w/portraits	first-person recall portraits	definitive
1890-01-01	Mag. of Art	Portraits of Browning, part 1			art lit	historical, educational, critical	Browning bio. via history w/portraits	first-person recall portraits	definitive
1890-05-01	Review	WMR comments for Moore's "Browning"			literature	historical	Browning history duality vision	first-person recall	definitive	Rossetti validates and extends Moore's point on vision.
1891-03-28	Athenaeum	WMR discovers ref. to Blake in Galt ed. Book			literature	historical, critical, educational	Browning ref. in Galt that Gilchrest missed	text	definitive	Blake "art for its own sweet sake.".
1892-12-24	Academy	WMR rebuts Scott's claims re: DGR			art	historical, polemical	Scott allegations WMR refutation	historical accuracy first-person ref.	rebuttal, definitive
1895-08-03	Athenaeum	Rebut announced CR edition, announce gift book			literature	historical	incorrect Athenaeum ref; news	facts	rebuttal	Gift book edited by Olivia Rossetti.
1895-11-16	Athenaeum	Correct paper error re: DGR "Hand and Soul"			literature	historical	incorrect newspaper reference	facts history	rebuttal	Story previously pub. in "The Germ" & The Fortnightly Review.
1898-05-01	Art Journal	WMR surveys a PRB collection	✓		art	critical, historical	PRB art collected; collector works	facts	evaluative, definitive	Leatheart's collection, "largest undispersed PRB collection."
1900-12-01	Athenaeum	WMR editorial error			art	critical, historical	DGR scraps; prev. pub; WMR error	facts discovery	definitive	WMR pub. DGR scrap in Pall Mall Gazette as un-pub. in error
1904-01-01	Mag. of Art	Clarify Marillier's "Record of DGR"	✓		art	critical, historical, polemical	Marillier correction DGR	facts history accuracy	rebuttal, definitive	Multiple corrections to Marillier favorable review.
1904-05-14	Athenaeum	WMR answer Symons query on Shelley reference			literature	historical	Shelley error; Browning-WMR emendation	Browning-WMR letter Shelley error	definitive	Shelley: Tower of Famine, Shelley error, WMR-Browning correct
1904-07-02	Athenaeum	WMR errors re: Mrs. Ruskin			literature	critical, historical	New info debunks previous conversation	facts new information	definitive	Previous conversations re: Mrs. Ruskin prove inaccurate.
1905-04-15	Athenaeum	WMR corrects attribution re: F.M. Brown & "Leaves"			art	critical, polemical	Incorrect attribution re: "Autumn Leaves"	personal knowledge family	definitive
1907-10-26	Athenaeum	WMR rebuts Grierson re: Shelley edit			literature	critical, historical	WMR clarifies Shelley edit; bio details.	facts historical accounts	rebuttal, definitive	Shelley edit.
1909-01-23	Athenaeum	Notice of British art & Ruskin memorial in Venice			art lit	journalistic, educational	Venice Brit art exhibit; Ruskin memorial	facts new information	definitive
1909-06-01	Bookman	WMR memorializes Swinburne			literature	critical, historical, educational	Swinburne memorialized	personal remembrance 50 years	epideictic, definitive	One of 12 critics memorializing Swinburne.
1909-10-01	Bookman	WMR retrospective of Ruskin			art lit	critical	WMR overview/retrospective re: Ruskin	Ruskin's work WMR appraisal	definitive, evaluative	One of 14 artists and critics offering opinions in essay.