Overview


Date 1892-12-24
Publication Academy
Topic WMR rebuts Scott's claims re: DGR
AP display
RA display
Subject art
Keywords Scott allegations
  ↳ WMR refutation
Standards historical accuracy
  ↳ first-person ref.
Notes

Annotation details

92 December 24 Academy

Topic:

Defending Dante Gabriel Rossetti against inaccurate claims attributed to Scott.

Citation:

Rossetti, William M. Untitled item. Academy (December 24, 1892): 304. Web. 21 Sept. 2011.

Summary:

Rossetti says that while several claims attributed to W. Bell Scott and about him are inaccurate, he's inclined to say nothing in response. But the claims concerning Dante Gabriel Rossetti must be rebutted, he tells the editor of Academy.

The claims are in regard to Dante Rossetti's financial status, as well as an alleged isolation from friends, and William Michael Rossetti denies both claims and refutes them with personal recollections and observations to the contrary.

Despite claiming he felt no need to do so, Rossetti nonetheless refutes Scott's description of his state of mind in regard to his brother Dante nonetheless. Rossetti quotes from The Germ to support his assertions.

Mode:

critical, polemical

Keywords:

false claims, rebuttal, fact, recollection

Standards of Judgment:

facts, personal recollections, documents

References:

William Sharp, Prof. Minto, William Bell-Scott, Dante Gabriel Rossetti, Mr. Brown

Rhetoric:

rebuttal

Writing technique/tone:

rebuttal, definition; insistent, uncompromising

Notable/quotable:

"I have here pointed out some of the misstatements . . ."