Overview


Date 1872-07-13
Publication Athenaeum
Topic Clarify Mary Queen of Scots verses
AP display
RA display
Subject literature
Keywords accuracy
  ↳ connotation
  ↳ context
Standards context
  ↳ connotation
Notes

Annotation details

72 July 13 Athenaeum

Topic:

clarify verses attributed to Mary Queen of Scots.

Citation:

Rossetti, William M. "Verses Attributed to Mary Queen of Scots." Athenaeum (July 13, 1872): 49. Web. 21 September 2011.

Summary:

In this letter to the editor Rossetti corrects and clarifies the translation of the verses attributed to Mary Queen of Scots, then explains why he believes the verses are in fact hers. Rossetti clarifies the mechanics of the translated verse, noting a qualitative departure from poetic convention in the tense shift in the French version. He then advances a theory of historical context that he believes confirms the origin of the verses, but closes with an appeal for others with insight to bring forward further evidence in order to more conclusively validate his theory.

Mode:

critical

Keywords:

endeavor to understand, clarify, translate, James the Fifth, Mary Queen of Scots

Standards of Judgment:

poetic theory, historical context

References:

Queen Mary, Ronsart, James the Fifth

Rhetoric:

evaluative

Writing technique/tone:

concise, brief, deliberate, educational, questioning

Notable/quotable:

parts of the verses published previously in The Athenaeum "are absolutely meaningless;" "internal evidence" supporting the authenticity of the verses.